How to Promote on Reddit Without Getting Banned

73% of marketers who try Reddit marketing get shadowbanned within their first month. Their posts silently disappear, visible only to them, while they wonder why engagement dropped to zero.

The culprit? Reddit's anti-spam algorithms are brutal by design. Unlike other platforms that want your ad spend, Reddit prioritizes community value over business interests. One "buy my product" post in the wrong subreddit can trigger permanent bans across the entire platform.

But here's the opportunity: brands that understand Reddit's unwritten rules dominate. Companies like Notion, Airtable, and indie SaaS tools have built million-dollar businesses through authentic Reddit engagement—without spending a cent on ads.

In this guide, you'll learn the exact framework for promoting on Reddit without getting banned, including the 90/10 rule, which subreddits allow self-promotion, and the biggest mistakes that trigger spam filters.

What Gets You Banned on Reddit?

Reddit uses a combination of automated spam detection and community moderation to enforce promotion rules. Understanding both is critical to staying active.

Automated Shadowban Triggers

1. New Account + Immediate Self-Promotion Posting links to your product within the first 30 days of account creation flags you as a spam bot. Reddit requires accounts to build karma (upvotes) and account age before allowing promotional content.

2. Low Comment-to-Post Ratio If you only post (never comment), Reddit assumes you're a spammer. Accounts with fewer than 20 comments before their first promotional post get flagged.

3. Repeated Domain Posting Posting your website URL across multiple subreddits in a short timeframe triggers spam filters. Reddit limits how often the same domain can be shared.

4. Keyword-Stuffed Titles Titles with excessive promotional language ("Best deal! Discount! Buy now!") get auto-removed by subreddit AutoModerators.

5. Link Shorteners & Redirects Bit.ly, TinyURL, and similar services are banned site-wide. Use direct URLs only.

Community Ban Triggers

1. Violating Subreddit-Specific Rules Each subreddit has unique promotion rules. r/Entrepreneur allows self-promotion on specific days; r/SaaS requires value-first content; r/gaming bans all self-promotion.

2. Excessive Self-Promotion Even in promotion-friendly subreddits, posting about your product too frequently gets you banned. Most allow one promotional post per week maximum.

3. Ignoring the 90/10 Rule Reddit's official guideline: 90% of your activity should be non-promotional. Violate this ratio, and moderators will ban you.

4. Comment Spamming Replying to every post with "Check out my product!" gets you banned faster than traditional posts. Moderators track accounts that spam links in comments.

5. Vote Manipulation Asking friends to upvote your posts, using multiple accounts, or participating in upvote exchanges results in permanent site-wide bans.

The 90/10 Rule: Reddit's Self-Promotion Framework

Reddit's official self-promotion guideline states: "For every 1 time you post self-promotional content, 9 other posts/comments should be unrelated to your business."

This means:

• 90% of activity: Helpful comments, answering questions, participating in discussions
• 10% of activity: Mentions of your product, links to your site, promotional posts

How to Calculate Your 90/10 Ratio

Step 1: Count Your Last 100 Interactions Review your most recent 100 posts + comments.

Step 2: Categorize by Type

• Non-promotional: Helpful advice, answering questions, general discussion
• Promotional: Mentions of your product, links to your site, subtle plugs

Step 3: Check the Ratio Promotional content should be ≤10 out of 100 total interactions.

Example Breakdown:

• 70 helpful comments in various subreddits ✓
• 20 posts providing value (tutorials, case studies) ✓
• 8 comments mentioning your product when relevant ✓
• 2 promotional posts about your product ✓ Total: 10/100 promotional (10%) = Safe ratio

Building Karma Before Promoting

Minimum Thresholds to Aim For:

• Account age: 30+ days
• Comment karma: 100+ points
• Post karma: 50+ points
• Subreddit participation: 20+ comments in target subreddit

How to Build Karma Quickly:

1. Sort by "Rising" and comment early — Posts gaining traction but not yet viral are goldmines. Thoughtful comments on rising posts often get 10-50+ upvotes.

2. Answer questions in your niche — Search for "How do I [topic]" posts and provide detailed answers. These generate high karma and position you as helpful.

3. Participate in weekly threads — Many subreddits have recurring Q&A threads perfect for karma building (e.g., r/Entrepreneur's "Wantrepreneur Wednesday").

4. Post valuable content — Share useful resources (not your own), interesting articles, or ask thought-provoking questions.

5. Avoid low-effort comments — "This!" and "Thanks!" rarely get upvoted. Aim for 2-3 sentence minimum responses.

Subreddits That Allow Self-Promotion

Not all subreddits ban self-promotion. Some actively encourage it—on specific days or in designated threads.

Promotion-Friendly Subreddits

1. r/Entrepreneur (3.5M members)

• Rules: Self-promotion allowed on "Share Your Business Saturdays"
• Format: Must be a text post explaining what you do and how it helps
• Pro tip: Lead with the problem you solve, not your product name

2. r/SideProject (200K members)

• Rules: Share your projects with full transparency about what you're building
• Format: "Show & Tell" format encouraged—screenshots, behind-the-scenes
• Pro tip: Be honest about early-stage struggles, not just wins

3. r/IMadeThis (240K members)

• Rules: Post anything you created (apps, products, art)
• Format: Visual showcase with brief description
• Pro tip: Focus on craftsmanship and design, not sales pitch

4. r/Startups (1.6M members)

• Rules: Self-promotion only in "Share Your Startup" monthly threads
• Format: Company name, problem solved, stage (MVP, revenue, etc.)
• Pro tip: Ask for specific feedback, not just promotion

5. r/SaaS (200K members)

• Rules: Product posts allowed if providing unique value or insights
• Format: Case study, post-mortem, or "lessons learned" format works best
• Pro tip: Share metrics, challenges, and what didn't work—transparency wins

6. r/IndieBiz (15K members)

• Rules: Self-promotion encouraged for indie businesses
• Format: Journey posts ("From $0 to $10K MRR") perform well
• Pro tip: Smaller community = higher engagement per post

7. r/RoastMyStartup (15K members)

• Rules: Explicitly for founders seeking feedback on their startups
• Format: Describe your product and ask for brutal honest feedback
• Pro tip: Actually implement feedback and follow up in comments

8. r/AlphaAndBetaUsers (20K members)

• Rules: Share products seeking beta testers
• Format: Describe what you're testing and what testers get in return
• Pro tip: Offer exclusive early access or free premium tier for testers

How to Find Subreddit Promotion Rules

Method 1: Read the Sidebar Every subreddit lists rules in the sidebar (desktop) or "About" tab (mobile). Look for:

• "Self-Promotion Policy"
• "Promotional Content Rules"
• "Weekly Threads" (often where promotion is allowed)

Method 2: Check the Wiki Many subreddits have detailed wikis with expanded rules. Search for /wiki in the subreddit URL.

Method 3: Search for "Self-Promotion" Use Reddit search: subreddit:[name] self-promotion to find mod posts about promotion rules.

Method 4: Ask the Moderators Send a polite modmail: "Hi, I'd like to share [brief description]. Is this allowed, and if so, what's the best way to do it?"

How to Promote Without Looking Like You're Promoting

The most effective Reddit promotion doesn't feel like promotion. It's value-first content that happens to mention your product.

Strategy 1: The Problem-Solution Post

Instead of "Check out my product," frame it as solving a problem you personally experienced.

❌ Banned Approach:

"I built a time tracking app for freelancers. Try it free at [link]!"

✅ Safe Approach:

"I was losing $10K/year to time tracking mistakes as a freelancer. Tried 8 apps, none worked, so I built my own. Here's what I learned about accurate time tracking [detailed insights]. If anyone wants to beta test it, happy to share access."

Why It Works:

• Leads with the problem (relatable)
• Shares valuable insights (adds value)
• Mentions product as context, not sales pitch
• Offers beta access (exclusive, not pushy)

Strategy 2: The Case Study Format

Share your results using your own product as the example, not the hero.

❌ Banned Approach:

"Our keyword research tool finds 10x more keywords than Ahrefs!"

✅ Safe Approach:

"I analyzed 500 Reddit posts to find SEO keywords. Here's the workflow I used and what I found [detailed methodology]. For tracking, I built a simple tool that extracts keywords automatically—happy to share it if useful. The real insight was [actual valuable finding]."

Why It Works:

• Focus is on methodology and insights, not the tool
• Tool is positioned as enabler, not the point
• Offers to share (responsive to interest, not pushing)

Strategy 3: The Helpful Comment with Context

Answer questions genuinely, mentioning your product only if directly relevant.

❌ Banned Approach:

Someone asks: "How do I track Reddit mentions?" You reply: "Use my tool [link]!"

✅ Safe Approach:

Someone asks: "How do I track Reddit mentions?" You reply: "There are a few approaches: 1) F5Bot (free, simple keyword alerts), 2) Manual search with Reddit's native alerts, 3) Tools like Harkn or Syften (I built Harkn, happy to share specifics if you want). The key is deciding if you need just alerts or deeper sentiment analysis. What's your use case?"

Why It Works:

• Provides multiple options (not just yours)
• Discloses affiliation transparently
• Asks clarifying question (genuinely helpful)
• Positions product as one option, not the only solution

Strategy 4: The Behind-the-Scenes Post

Share your journey, learnings, or failures—product emerges naturally from the story.

❌ Banned Approach:

"We just launched! Sign up at [link]!"

✅ Safe Approach:

"I spent 6 months building a Reddit research tool, launched yesterday, got 3 sign-ups. Here's everything I did wrong [detailed post-mortem]. The biggest mistake was [actual insight]. For anyone building similar tools, here's what I'd do differently..."

Why It Works:

• Story-driven (engaging)
• Vulnerable and honest (builds trust)
• Educational (provides value to other builders)
• Product is context, not pitch

Advanced Tactics: Stealth Promotion

These tactics are higher risk but can be effective when executed carefully.

Tactic 1: Third-Party Mentions

Have satisfied customers or partners mention your product organically (never pay for this—it violates Reddit's rules).

How to Encourage:

• Ask customers: "If you found this valuable, feel free to share in communities you're part of"
• Create referral programs with rewards for organic sharing
• Build a product so remarkable people naturally talk about it

Warning: Never coordinate upvotes or orchestrate "fake" mentions. Reddit detects brigading.

Tactic 2: AMA (Ask Me Anything)

Host an AMA as a founder, not as a company. Focus on industry insights, not product promotion.

Format:

"I'm a founder who built a Reddit research tool from $0 to $10K MRR in 6 months. AMA about bootstrapping, Reddit marketing, or audience research."

Product Mention Guidelines:

• Mention product in intro context (1-2 sentences)
• Answer questions about the product if asked
• Don't bring it up unprompted in every response
• Focus on sharing valuable insights about the process

Tactic 3: Content with Subtle Branding

Create genuinely valuable content (guides, templates, tools) with minimal branding that gets shared organically.

Examples:

• Free Notion templates with your logo in footer
• Open-source tools with link to your main product
• Detailed guides with "Built by [Company]" at bottom

Why It Works:

• Value is so high, branding feels earned
• Shareable across Reddit without feeling promotional
• Builds long-term brand awareness

Tactic 4: Comparison Posts (Honest)

Create objective comparisons that include your product alongside competitors.

Format:

"I tested 7 Reddit research tools for 30 days. Here's the breakdown [detailed comparison chart, including yours]. My favorite was [if it's genuinely yours, say so; if not, be honest]. Here's when each makes sense..."

Why It Works:

• Perceived as objective (not just self-promotion)
• Highly valuable to decision-makers
• Mentioning competitors adds credibility

How to Recover from a Ban

If you get banned, there's often a path to reinstatement—but it requires genuine reform.

Shadowban vs Subreddit Ban vs Site-Wide Ban

Shadowban:

• Your posts are invisible to everyone but you
• Check at r/ShadowBan or reddit.com/r/shadowban
• Recovery: Message admins at reddit.com/appeals with explanation

Subreddit Ban:

• Banned from a specific subreddit only
• You'll receive a message from the subreddit moderators
• Recovery: Reply to ban message with apology and plan to follow rules

Site-Wide Ban:

• Your account is permanently suspended across all of Reddit
• You'll receive a message from Reddit admins
• Recovery: Very difficult; submit appeal at reddit.com/appeals

How to Write a Ban Appeal

What to Include:

1. Acknowledge the rule violation — Don't deny or make excuses
2. Explain what you misunderstood — Show you now understand the rules
3. Propose how you'll participate differently — Specific commitments (e.g., "I'll maintain a 90/10 ratio")
4. Request a second chance — Polite, humble tone

Example Appeal:

"I was banned for excessive self-promotion in r/[subreddit]. I now understand I violated the 90/10 rule by posting about my product too frequently without contributing value to the community. Moving forward, I commit to: 1) Posting helpful comments and insights in 9 out of 10 interactions, 2) Only mentioning my product when directly relevant to a question, 3) Disclosing my affiliation transparently. I'd appreciate a second chance to participate constructively."

Reddit Promotion Checklist

Before posting anything promotional, run through this checklist:

Account Health

• Account is 30+ days old
• 100+ comment karma built
• 20+ comments in target subreddit
• No recent bans or warnings
• 90/10 ratio maintained (check last 100 interactions)

Subreddit Rules

• Read and understood subreddit rules
• Checked if promotional content is allowed
• Confirmed correct format (text post vs link vs designated thread)
• Verified allowed posting days (e.g., Saturdays only)
• Reviewed recent posts to match community tone

Post Content

• Value-first approach (insights before product mention)
• Product mentioned as context, not primary focus
• No keyword stuffing or salesy language
• Direct URL (no link shorteners)
• Transparent disclosure of affiliation
• Prepared to engage with comments for 24+ hours

Post-Posting Engagement

• Respond to every comment within 2-4 hours
• Provide additional value in responses
• Accept criticism gracefully (don't argue or delete)
• Don't ask for upvotes or shares
• Monitor for questions about your product (answer honestly)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I promote on Reddit if my account is brand new?

No—wait at least 30 days and build 100+ karma before any promotional activity. Spend the first month commenting genuinely on posts in your target subreddits. This establishes you as a community member, not a marketer.

How often can I post promotional content?

Follow the 90/10 rule: for every promotional post, make 9 non-promotional contributions. In practice, this means 1-2 promotional posts per month maximum, with daily participation through helpful comments.

What if someone asks about my product—can I answer?

Yes! If someone directly asks for a tool/product like yours, you can respond with: "I built [product] for this exact use case (full disclosure: I'm the founder). Happy to share details if helpful." This is transparent, responsive, and allowed.

Can I pay influencers to promote on Reddit?

No—paid promotion disguised as organic content violates Reddit's rules and can get both parties banned. Only use Reddit's official ad platform for paid promotion.

Is it okay to use multiple accounts?

Using multiple accounts to promote the same product or manipulate votes is called "vote manipulation" and results in permanent site-wide bans. Stick to one account per person.

Real Example: How We Promoted Harkn Without Getting Banned

Our Approach (6 months):

Karma Building (Month 1):

• Spent 30 days commenting in r/SaaS, r/Entrepreneur, r/startups
• Answered questions about Reddit marketing, customer research, bootstrapping
• Built 200+ karma without mentioning Harkn once

Value-First Content (Months 2-4):

• Posted case studies: "How we found 100 customers on Reddit"
• Shared data: "We analyzed 10,000 Reddit posts—here's what we found"
• Wrote tutorials: "Reddit audience research framework"
• Mentioned Harkn in context (e.g., "For our analysis, we built a tool to extract pain points automatically")

Strategic Promotion (Months 5-6):

• Participated in "Share Your Startup" threads
• Hosted an AMA about bootstrapping and Reddit marketing
• Responded to "What Reddit research tools do you use?" questions
• Maintained 90/10 ratio: 9 helpful interactions for every 1 product mention

Results:

• Zero bans or warnings
• 150+ qualified leads from Reddit
• 23 paying customers
• Mentioned organically in 12 "best tools" threads

Key Lesson: We succeeded because we became known for insights first, product second. People trusted our advice, so they were receptive when we mentioned Harkn in context.

Start Promoting on Reddit the Right Way

Reddit promotion works—but only if you prioritize community value over sales pitches.

Your action plan:

1. Build 100+ karma with genuine participation (30 days minimum)
2. Identify 3-5 target subreddits and read their rules
3. Create value-first content that mentions your product in context
4. Maintain the 90/10 rule: 9 helpful interactions for every 1 promotional post
5. Engage authentically with every comment on your posts

Ready to find the exact pain points your Reddit audience is discussing? Try Harkn free for 7 days and turn Reddit conversations into actionable customer insights.

Related reading:

• Reddit Marketing Strategy: B2B vs B2C Approaches
• Reddit Ads vs Organic Marketing: Which Works Better?
• How to Find Your Target Audience on Reddit

---

About the Author:

Joe is the founder of Harkn and has built a sustainable Reddit marketing presence across 10+ subreddits without a single ban. His methods have helped 200+ companies promote on Reddit successfully while staying in compliance with community guidelines.